• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Irish America

Irish America

Irish America

  • HOME
  • WHO WE ARE
    • ABOUT US
    • IRISH AMERICA TEAM
  • IN THIS ISSUE
  • HALL OF FAME
  • THE LISTS
    • BUSINESS 100
    • HALL OF FAME
    • HEALTH AND LIFE SCIENCES 50
    • WALL STREET 50
  • LIBRARY
  • TRAVEL
  • EVENTS

Photo Album: Toomey’s Diner

By Peg Toomey Fisk

Fall 2026

October 9, 2026 by Leave a Comment

John Toomey (originally Twomey) second from left, behind the counter in Toomey’s Diner in Brooklyn.

Michael Twomey emigrated to the U.S. in the 1880s from County Cork.

The Twomeys primarily settled across the New York and New England region.

My dad, John Toomey (the name changed from Twomey to Toomey on arrival in America), and his brother owned and operated Toomey’s Diner in Brooklyn on the corner of Rogers Avenue and Empire Blvd, from 1935 to 1965. Since it was only two blocks from Ebbets Field, most people who ate there were rabid Brooklyn Dodgers fans and some of the Dodger players.

My dad used to have a little section for “crying towels” for those Brooklyn Bums who used to say, “Wait until next year.”

In my teen years, I was a waitress at Toomey’s, although I wasn’t old enough to serve beer and had to have another waitress carry it to the table.

Opening day at Ebbets Field, 1913.

My dad used to warn me not to keep playing the jukebox with my tips and say, “You’ll never be able to go to college if you don’t save your money.”

Toomey’s was a friendly place, and I knew most of the patrons, but one day a grubby guy came in and yelled at me while I was trying to clean the table he was sitting at. When my father heard the four-letter words this guy was spewing, he asked him to leave (accompanied out by the short-order cooks).

I was always so proud of my dad when he told the guy, “Nobody treats my waitresses like that.” He never mentioned I was his daughter.

When the Dodgers won the World Series, the diner went wild. “Next year is here!” the pennant in Toomey’s read.

A few weeks later, while I was waiting on the lunch crowd, a hush fell over the place. I went over to the table of men, and even I recognized Johnny Podres, the winning Dodger pitcher. I was cool, though, and only dropped my pencil twice.

My dad sold the diner in the early 60s, and the place is still there. It doesn’t look the same, but luckily my memories do.


Peg Toomey Fisk, John Toomey’s daughter, and aunt to Wall St. 50 honoree Chris Toomey, who submitted the above  photo of his great grandfather, Michael. 

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Highlights

News
Articles and stories from Irish America.....
MORE

Hibernia
News from Ireland and happenings in Irish America.....
MORE

Those We Lost
Remembering some of the great Irish Americans who have passed.....
MORE

Slainte!
Discover Irish ancestry, predilections, and recipes.....
MORE

Photo Album
Irish America readers share the stories of their ancestors....
MORE

More Articles

  • Irish Eye on Hollywood

    Irish Eye on Hollywood

    Walk the Blue Fields Movie productions don’t get much more Irish than the forthcoming romantic dr...
  • View from the Eastern Front of the War on Ukraine

    View from the Eastern Front of the War on Ukraine

    Kharkiv: Russia’s war on Ukraine looks different up close. It’s a mix of extreme danger and everyday...
  • Sea Voyages With Father

    Sea Voyages With Father

    Annie Burke shares memories of how her father, Jim Burke, helped her overcome childhood respiratory ...
  • family album |  The Road to Bright City

    family album |  The Road to Bright City

    My grandfather John Bernard “Barney” Hynes and his brother, Thomas J. Hynes emigrated in their early...

Footer

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Subscribe

  • Subscribe
  • Give a Gift
  • Newsletter

Additional

  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2026 · IrishAmerica Child Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in